Wednesday, October 4, 2006
Search DH  
Home | About Us | Subscribe | Contact Us | Archives | Feedback | DH Avenues




 

News
National
State
District
City
Business
Foreign
Sports
Comment
Edit Page
Panorama
Net Mail
Your Take
Your Space
Infoline
In City Today
Helpline
Daily Almanac
Festivals of India
Weather
Leisure
Crossword
Horoscope 
Year 2006
Weekly
Daily Astrospeak 
 
Annual Chinese Horoscope - 2006 
 
Calendar 2006

Pearls of wisdom
"Whatever punishment does to a nation it does not induce a sense of guilt." Anne O’Hare McCormick

 
Supplements
Economy & Business
'WINNING' with Jack & Suzy Welch
Metro Life - Mon
Science & Technology
Spectrum
DH Avenues
Cyber Space
Metro Life - Thurs
Sport scene
DH Education
  English For You
 
Studying in India 
 
Studying Abroad
Metro Friday
Living
She
Personal Tech
Open Sesame
DH Realty
Metro Life - Sat
Sunday Herald
Fine Art / Culture
Articulations
Entertainment
Reviews
Book Reviews
Movie Reviews
Art Reviews
Columns
Kuldip Nayar
Khushwant Singh
N J Nanporia
Tavleen Singh
Swami
Sukhbodhananda
Bittu Sahgal
Suresh Menon
Shreekumar Varma
Movie Guide
Ad Links
Deccan
International School
Real Estate Properties in Bangalore
Deccan Herald
Now Available
Globally
in Print Format
Others
About Us
Subscription

Send your Suggestions / Queries about the Website to the
Webmaster


To send letters to Editor : 
Letters to Editor

You are welcome to post your letters/responses to NETMAIL here.

For enquiries on advertisements :
Contact Us

 
Deccan Herald » Panorama » Detailed Story
ANALYSIS
He stuck to his dream of a united Mysore
By Vikram Sampath
Tipu Sultan had his failings and weaknesses but he cannot be denied the greatness that he so richly deserves.
 
An unwarranted controversy brews over the life and times of a man who laid down his life fighting for his freedom some 207 years ago. Tipu Sultan has kicked up dust in a country starved of sensationalism. The genesis of this sordid tale was an irrelevant reference to the 18th century ruler by the Karnataka Higher Education Minister. That the comment was purposeless, illogical and out-of-context should have sufficed for the paparazzi to abandon it. But presto! – we have an entire ‘‘secularists’ brigade” – from writers to supposed thinkers to defunct politicians and television stars, jumping the gun and converting it into a communal issue. The minister never made a reference to religion in his diatribe. But could our friends miss an opportunity when they could publicly proclaim their love for minorities? After all, in India a person becomes secular by branding another communal! Do we, in the 21st century, need to sit in judgement of a monarch who ruled the land 200 years ago? And worse, by present-day yardsticks of morality and political correctness?

The basic premise of Tipu being ‘‘anti-Kannada’’ seems misplaced. Judging a king who ruled two centuries ago by the present standards of virulent “Kannada nationalism” is preposterous! In 1916, R Narasimhachar, Director of Archaeology in Mysore, unearthed over 30 letters written by the Sultan in chaste Kannada to the Sringeri Shankaracharya. The Mir Asaf Kacheri (Revenue and Finance Department) maintained records in Persian, Kannada and Marathi. Persian was certainly introduced with Kannada for official and military use. Just as Marathi and Kannada enjoyed equal status in the Wodeyar Court, the introduction of Persian made the administration multi-lingual.

What is interesting is that Tipu obliterated every trace of the Wodeyars, whose kingdom was usurped by his father Haidar Ali in 1761. The name of every object (years, months, weights, coins, forts, and official designations) was changed. The administration was called “Sarkar-e-Khudadad” or God-given government. Mangalore became Jalalabad, Mysore became Nazarabad and Srirangapatna was Ganjam. The motive, it would appear was to leave his mark on the affairs of a usurped state and send a message to the members of the displaced Royal Family under Rani Lakshmi Ammanni who were conspiring with the British to oust him.


Love or hatred for Kannada seems to be the last thing on Tipu’s mind, and it was a completely political move by a man who was after all a king, not a saint or Kannada litterateur! Regarding Tipu’s secular credentials, he was undoubtedly liberal in many of his gestures within Mysore – his letters to Shankaracharya, the donations to Sringeri, Nanjangud and Srirangapatna temples permitting the Dasara festivities etc. But the same Tipu adopted a violent and intolerant attitude outside Mysore. Malabar, that bore the brunt of his vitriolic attacks, has records that throw light on this fact. Mysorean armies along with Mappillas or local Muslim tribes, ravaged the lives of thousands of rebelling Hindu Nairs, coupled with forceful conversions and destruction of temples. Thrichambaram and Thalipparampu (Chirackal), Thiruvangatu (Tellicherry) and Ponmeri (Badakara), Keraladheeswaram, Thrikkandiyoor and Thriprangatu (Vettum) temples were destroyed.

Tipu writes to Syed Abdul Dulai on January 18, 1790: “With the grace of Prophet Mohammed and Allah, almost all Hindus in Calicut are converted to Islam. Only on the borders of Cochin State a few are still not converted. I am determined to convert them also very soon.” It could be argued that more than religion, it was the victor’s power that had to be established.

What better way to do it than enforcing one’s religious identity on the vanquished? But even by today's “secular” standards, isn't this the wrong approach to quell insurgency, in say Kashmir or the North East?

A historian’s role should be one of equanimity and conscious adherence to facts. Undoubtedly, Tipu was a great ruler and visionary ahead of his time. His understanding of British imperialism, vision of a united anti-British Indian confederacy and bravery are folklore. Strangely, he allied with the French, who were no less imperialistic! But that was Tipu – a bundle of contradictions.

At the end of the day he was a human being and a man with shades of grey. He had his failings, weaknesses and committed some terrible excesses that contemporary monarchs were guilty of. Modern historians need not brush these facts under the carpet. But at the same time, Tipu cannot be denied the greatness that he so richly deserves.

As Denys Forrest states, "Looking back over his story, I think it can be seen that he had a rare quality of single-mindedness. As in the style of his letters, so in the shape of his life, Tipu Sultan was always recognisably himself. That is why the English feared him, even beyond reason. And he was a brave man. He may have fallen short in wisdom and foresight, but never in courage, never in aspiration, never in his dream of a united, an independent, a prosperous Mysore.”

(The writer is with Citibank, and has put together a work on the 'History of Mysore'.)
Comment on this article
 
Other Headlines
Eyes on the prize »
He stuck to his dream of a united Mysore »
The kitsch lives on »
Teach English. Not in English »
Tax for all »
Ad Links
Flowers cakes gifts to Bangalore Mumbai India
 
Seeking Marriage Proposals? Find your compatible Life Partner from Millions @ Shaadi.com. 1000's of New Profiles added everyday.
 
Flowers to India, Send gifts to India, Bangalore, Chennai, Hyderabad, Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata
 
The grand $0 offer! NRI's invest now!
  
 
Florist Flowers Gifts Delhi Bangalore Mumbai
 
 
Discount, on, Apparels, Shoes, Computers, Music and Electronics.  
 
 
Flowers to Bangalore, Chennai, Hyderabad, Delhi, Mumbai, Pune, Kolkata.
 
 
Send Flowers, Cakes, Chocolate, Fruits to Pune.
 
 
Send Gift Cake Flower India Online
 
 
Flowers  to India, France, Japan, Germany, Hong Kong, Singapore, Indonesia
Copyright 2005, The Printers (Mysore) Private Ltd., 75, M.G. Road, Post Box No 5331, Bangalore - 560001
Tel: +91 (80) 25880000 Fax No. +91 (80) 25880523